Treatment Guide

Therapy for Insecurity: What CBT and Attachment Research Shows

Therapy for insecurity: weekly CBT for low self-esteem showed a 1.12 effect size in a 2018 meta-analysis. How compassion-focused and couples therapy compare.

Mental Health Stats Research Team 6 min read

Key Takeaways

  • In a 2018 meta-analysis of CBT built on Fennell's model of low self-esteem, weekly sessions produced a summary effect size of 1.12 on self-report measures, versus 0.34 for one-day workshops[1].1.12[1]
  • Compassion-focused therapies raised self-esteem by a medium effect (g = 0.56) across 8 studies in a 2021 review, though the studies differed widely[2].g = 0.56[2]
  • Across 77 longitudinal studies, low self-esteem predicted later depression (β = −.16) more strongly than depression predicted later self-esteem (β = −.08)[3].77 studies[3]
  • In a 2018 meta-analysis of 36 studies and 3,158 patients, people with secure attachment before treatment had better psychotherapy outcomes than insecurely attached patients[4].3,158[4]
  • Emotionally focused couples therapy improved relationship satisfaction by g = 0.73 at the end of treatment in a 2019 meta-analysis of 33 randomized trials[5].g = 0.73[5]
  • About 1 in 7 U.S. adults (14.0%) received counseling or therapy from a mental health professional in 2024[6].14.0%[6]

Therapy for Insecurity: What the Evidence Shows

Therapy for insecurity has no single protocol, because insecurity is a feeling rather than a diagnosis. The APA Dictionary of Psychology defines it as a feeling of inadequacy, lack of self-confidence and inability to cope, accompanied by uncertainty and anxiety about one's goals, abilities or relationships with others[7].

Researchers study it through two narrower ideas: low self-esteem and insecure attachment. The strongest trial evidence is for cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) aimed at low self-esteem, where a 2018 meta-analysis found a summary effect size of 1.12 for weekly sessions[1].

Insecurity often travels with depression and anxiety, and national rates for diagnosable conditions are tracked on the any mental illness page. This article covers what therapy does for insecurity itself.

The evidence base is small. The 2018 CBT review found only 8 eligible studies, and its authors wrote that it is unclear whether these programs differ from CBT aimed at depression[1].

Insecurity

A feeling of inadequacy, lack of self-confidence and inability to cope, accompanied by general uncertainty and anxiety about one's goals, abilities or relationships with others[7]. Research usually measures it as low self-esteem or as insecure (anxious or avoidant) attachment[4].

Related Terms

low self-esteem
insecure attachment
self-criticism
attachment anxiety
attachment avoidance

Source: APA Dictionary of Psychology

Is Insecurity a Mental Illness?

No diagnostic category exists for insecurity, low self-esteem or insecure attachment, so there is no prevalence figure for them the way there is for depression or anxiety.

Insecurity is linked to both. A 2013 meta-analysis of 77 longitudinal studies found that low self-esteem predicted later depression (β = −.16) more strongly than depression predicted later self-esteem (β = −.08)[3].

For anxiety, across 18 studies, the effects ran about equally in both directions (β = −.10 and −.08)[3]. These are associations from observational data, and the authors described the causal role of low self-esteem as a hypothesis for future research to confirm[3].

The self-esteem and depression link did not differ significantly by gender, age, the scales used or the time between measurements, and samples ranged from childhood to old age[3].

Adult insecure attachment is also distinct from the childhood conditions covered on the attachment disorders page. It describes a style of relating to close others, not a disorder[4].

CBT for Low Self-Esteem: The Most-Studied Approach

The CBT studies covered here use Fennell's 1997 cognitive conceptualisation of low self-esteem, a transdiagnostic approach meant for people with a range of different and co-occurring disorders[8].

A 2018 systematic review identified 8 studies using this model and pooled 7 of them[1]. Weekly group or individual sessions produced a summary effect size of 1.12, and one-day workshops produced 0.34, both with low heterogeneity[1].

Depressive symptoms fell by a comparable amount in the same studies[1]. The outcomes were self-report measures, not clinician ratings[1].

Randomized evidence is thin. In a 2012 primary care study, 22 participants were randomized either to 10 sessions of individual CBT with workbooks or to a waitlist[8].

The treated group scored better on self-esteem, overall functioning and depression, and had fewer psychiatric diagnoses by the end of treatment[8]. Gains held at an 11-week follow-up, although the sample was mostly women with high educational attainment[8].

Participants on the waitlist showed the same pattern of improvement once they received CBT, a pattern consistent with a treatment effect[8].

Summary effect size of weekly CBT sessions for low self-esteem (Fennell model)
1.12

Pooled from 7 studies in a 2018 meta-analysis. One-day workshops using the same model produced 0.34. Both figures come from self-report measures.

"Summary effect sizes of 1.12 and 0.34 at post-treatment were observed"

Psychiatry Research(2018) View Source

Compassion-Focused Therapy and Self-Criticism

Self-criticism is the process of negative self-evaluation, and self-compassion interventions were developed to target it directly[9]. Compassion-focused therapy (CFT) is one clinical form.

A 2022 meta-analysis of 19 randomized trials with 1,350 participants found these interventions reduced self-criticism by a medium effect (g = 0.51) compared with control groups[9]. Reductions were larger when programs ran longer and when the comparison was a passive control rather than an active treatment[9].

On self-esteem itself, a 2021 review found 10 eligible papers, and within-group data from 8 studies showed a medium effect (g = 0.56)[2]. Within-group effects compare scores before and after treatment rather than against a control group, and the authors flagged large clinical and methodological differences between studies[2].

When the lowest-quality studies were removed, the effect rose slightly to g = 0.61 and remained significant[2].

Schema therapy, another approach built around long-standing beliefs about the self, is covered in the schema therapy explainer.

Therapy for Insecurity: Results From Major Reviews

ApproachOutcome measuredEvidence basePooled effect
CBT, weekly sessions (Fennell model)Self-esteem7 pooled studies (2018)1.12
CBT, one-day workshopSelf-esteem7 pooled studies (2018)0.34
Psychotherapy for depressionSelf-esteem vs. control19 RCTs, 3,423 adults (2023)g = 0.63
Compassion-focused therapiesSelf-esteem, before vs. after8 studies (2021)g = 0.56
Self-compassion interventionsSelf-criticism vs. control19 RCTs, 1,350 people (2022)g = 0.51
Emotionally focused couples therapyRelationship satisfaction33 RCTs incl. BCT, 2,730 people (2019)g = 0.73
Behavioral couple therapyRelationship satisfaction33 RCTs incl. EFCT, 2,730 people (2019)g = 0.53

Pooled effect sizes at the end of treatment from meta-analyses published 2018 to 2023[1][10][2][9][5]. Higher values mean larger average improvement.

1Designs differ: the CFT figure is a before-and-after comparison without a control group, while the others compare against controls[2].

2The CBT review reported summary effect sizes without labeling them as Hedges' g[1].

3Couples trials measured relationship satisfaction, not insecurity directly[5].

Sources

  • •Kolubinski et al., 2018
  • •Bhattacharya et al., 2023
  • •Thomason & Moghaddam, 2021
  • •Wakelin et al., 2022
  • •Rathgeber et al., 2019

Therapy for Insecurity in Relationships and Insecure Attachment

Relationship insecurity is usually studied as attachment style. A 2018 meta-analysis describes three patterns: secure (healthy interdependence with others), anxious (overdependence on others) and avoidant (difficulty relying on others)[4].

Across 36 studies and 3,158 patients, people who were securely attached before treatment had better psychotherapy outcomes than those who were insecurely attached[4]. Improvements in attachment security during therapy tended to coincide with better outcomes[4].

Preliminary analyses in the same review suggested that people low in attachment security may do better in therapy that focuses on interpersonal interactions and close relationships[4].

Attachment style itself appears to shift. A 2015 systematic review found attachment security rose and attachment anxiety fell after therapy, across patient groups and therapy types, while results for attachment avoidance were unclear[11]. Approaches for the avoidant pattern are covered in CBT for avoidant attachment.

For couples, a 2019 meta-analysis of 33 randomized trials with 2,730 participants found emotionally focused couples therapy improved relationship satisfaction by g = 0.73 and behavioral couple therapy by g = 0.53, with no significant difference between the two[5].

At 6 months the effects were smaller (g = 0.66 and g = 0.35), and the only 12-month data, for behavioral couple therapy, showed the gain had faded (g = 0.06)[5]. The authors cautioned about possible publication bias[5].

How to read these numbers: An effect size describes how far the average treated person moved, compared with a control group or with their own starting point. The reviews cited here described values from about 0.5 to 0.6 as medium[2][9][5]. Most self-esteem studies relied on self-report questionnaires, and the 2012 randomized CBT trial had 22 participants[1][8].

When Insecurity Comes With Depression or Anxiety

Psychotherapy for depression also tends to raise self-esteem. In a 2023 meta-analysis of 19 trials with 3,423 adults, psychotherapy for depression had a large effect on depression (g = −0.95) and a moderate effect on self-esteem (g = 0.63)[10].

Trials that reduced depression more also raised self-esteem more (β = −0.60)[10]. The evidence has limits: heterogeneity was very high (I² = 97%), and only 6 of the 19 trials were rated low risk of bias[10].

The self-esteem effect at 6 to 12 months was g = 0.70, but its confidence interval crossed zero (−0.03 to 1.43), so durability is uncertain[10].

This fits the longitudinal finding that low self-esteem and depression are linked in both directions, with the stronger path running from low self-esteem to later depression[3].

When fear of judgment leads to avoiding people, clinicians may assess for social anxiety disorder or avoidant personality disorder, which are diagnosable conditions with their own treatment evidence.

How Long Therapy for Insecurity Takes and Who Gets Therapy

The structured programs in these trials were short. The 2012 CBT trial used 10 individual sessions[8], and the 2018 review pooled weekly courses alongside single-day workshops[1].

Format mattered for CBT: one-day workshops produced about a third of the effect of weekly sessions (0.34 vs. 1.12)[1]. For self-compassion programs, longer interventions reduced self-criticism more, while delivery format made no significant difference[9].

Use of therapy has grown. In 2024, 14.0% of U.S. adults received counseling or therapy from a mental health professional in the past 12 months, compared with 9.5% in 2019[6][12].

Women (16.9%) were more likely than men (10.9%) to receive counseling, and adults ages 18 to 29 (20.2%) were the most likely of any age group[6].

Costs and lower-fee options are covered in affordable therapy, and the differences between counselors, psychologists and psychiatrists in kinds of therapists.

What the Research on Therapy for Insecurity Does Not Yet Show

None of the reviews cited here compared CBT, compassion-focused therapy and attachment-focused therapy head to head for insecurity. The figures in the table above come from separate reviews with different designs, populations and outcomes[1][2][5].

Follow-up periods are short. The randomized CBT trial followed people for 11 weeks after treatment[8], and the depression review's 6-to-12-month self-esteem estimate was not statistically certain[10].

Controlled trials are scarce. The self-compassion review called for more trials with active controls, follow-ups and diverse samples[9], and the attachment review said further controlled trials are needed to confirm that attachment style changes in therapy[11].

Gains in couples work may also fade. In the 2019 review, behavioral couple therapy's effect fell from g = 0.53 at the end of treatment to g = 0.06 at 12 months, an estimate the review reported for behavioral couple therapy only[5].

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources & References

  1. Kolubinski DC, Frings D, Nikčević AV, Lawrence JA, Spada MM. A systematic review and meta-analysis of CBT interventions based on the Fennell model of low self-esteem. Psychiatry Research. Published 2018. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30201116/ [Link]
  2. Thomason S, Moghaddam N. Compassion-focused therapies for self-esteem: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice. Published 2021. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33215861/ [Link]
  3. Sowislo JF, Orth U. Does low self-esteem predict depression and anxiety? A meta-analysis of longitudinal studies. Psychological Bulletin. Published 2013. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22730921/ [Link]
  4. Levy KN, Kivity Y, Johnson BN, Gooch CV. Adult attachment as a predictor and moderator of psychotherapy outcome: a meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Psychology. Published 2018. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30238450/ [Link]
  5. Rathgeber M, Bürkner PC, Schiller EM, Holling H. The efficacy of emotionally focused couples therapy and behavioral couples therapy: a meta-analysis. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy. Published 2019. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29781200/ [Link]
  6. National Center for Health Statistics. Mental Health Treatment Among Adults: United States, 2024 (NCHS Data Brief No. 564). National Center for Health Statistics, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Published 2026. Accessed October 2026. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db564.htm [Link]
  7. American Psychological Association. Insecurity. APA Dictionary of Psychology, American Psychological Association. Published 2018. Accessed October 2026. https://dictionary.apa.org/insecurity [Link]
  8. Waite P, McManus F, Shafran R. Cognitive behaviour therapy for low self-esteem: a preliminary randomized controlled trial in a primary care setting. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry. Published 2012. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22683442/ [Link]
  9. Wakelin KE, Perman G, Simonds LM. Effectiveness of self-compassion-related interventions for reducing self-criticism: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy. Published 2022. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33749936/ [Link]
  10. Bhattacharya S, Kennedy M, Miguel C, Tröger A, Hofmann SG, Cuijpers P. Effect of psychotherapy for adult depression on self-esteem: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Affective Disorders. Published 2023. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36642316/ [Link]
  11. Taylor P, Rietzschel J, Danquah A, Berry K. Changes in attachment representations during psychological therapy. Psychotherapy Research. Published 2015. Accessed October 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24559454/ [Link]
  12. National Center for Health Statistics. Mental Health Treatment Among Adults: United States, 2019 (NCHS Data Brief No. 380). National Center for Health Statistics, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Published 2020. Accessed October 2026. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db380.htm [Link]

Related Statistics