Explainer

Retail Therapy: Does Shopping Really Lift Mood? The Research

Retail therapy eased sadness in short-term experiments, but about 4.9% of adults show compulsive buying, a 2016 meta-analysis of 40 studies found.

Mental Health Stats Research Team 7 min read

Key Takeaways

  • Three experiments published in 2014 supported the finding that making shopping choices reduces lingering sadness, whether the choices are hypothetical or real[1].3 experiments[1]
  • In a 2011 study, unplanned self-treats bought to repair a bad mood were not associated with regret or guilt[2].No regret[2]
  • Sad, self-focused participants set an average buying price of $2.11 for a water bottle, versus $0.56 among neutral participants, in a 2008 experiment[3].$2.11 vs. $0.56[3]
  • About 4.9% of adults in representative samples show compulsive buying behavior, according to a 2016 meta-analysis of 40 studies[4].4.9%[4]
  • For compulsive buying, psychological treatment outperformed control groups (g = 0.75, 6 studies), while medication did not beat control in 2 controlled comparisons, a 2020 meta-analysis found[5].g = 0.75[5]

What Is Retail Therapy?

Retail therapy is the everyday name for shopping, or buying small treats, to lift a bad mood. Researchers who studied it in 2011 described retail therapy as "trying to cheer oneself up through the purchase of self-treats"[2].

Despite the name, it is a consumer-psychology idea, not a clinical treatment. The studies behind it measure short-lived sadness and bad moods, not diagnosed mental illness, whose national rates are tracked separately.

The research splits into two lines. Consumer psychologists have tested whether shopping repairs ordinary sadness, and psychiatrists have studied compulsive buying disorder, in which shopping driven by mood becomes excessive and causes distress or impairment[6].

Does Retail Therapy Work? What the Experiments Found

Two consumer-psychology papers that tested retail therapy directly both found a mood benefit. In the 2011 Psychology & Marketing study, a bad mood led people to buy and consume more unplanned treats for themselves, and those purchases had lasting positive effects on mood[2].

The same study found that regret and guilt were not associated with unplanned purchases made to repair a bad mood[2]. People who indulged could also hold back when restraint would improve their mood, which the authors read as evidence that retail therapy can be strategic rather than mindless[2].

A 2014 Journal of Consumer Psychology paper reported 3 experiments supporting the finding that making shopping choices reduces residual sadness, whether the choices are hypothetical or real[1]. The authors traced the effect to personal control: sadness is tied to a sense that situational forces drive outcomes, and choosing among products restores some control over one's environment[1].

The benefit did not extend to anger, which the authors link to blaming other people rather than circumstances[1]. Both papers studied ordinary sadness and bad moods; neither tested shopping as a treatment for clinical depression.

Why Shopping Can Feel Good During a Bad Mood

Restored personal control is one explanation for why shopping can ease sadness[1]. A second line of research shows that sadness also raises how much people are willing to pay, an effect researchers call "misery is not miserly"[3].

In the 2004 experiment that first documented the effect, people induced to feel sad gave up 30% more money to acquire an item than people in a neutral mood[3][7]. In a 2008 follow-up with 33 young adults, sad participants set an average buying price of $2.11 for an insulated water bottle, compared with $0.56 among neutral participants[3].

The effect appeared only when self-focus was high, measured by how often participants wrote words such as "I," "me" and "my"[3]. The authors proposed that sadness combined with self-focus lowers a person's sense of self, and that valuing new possessions more is an implicit attempt to enhance it[3].

A 2018 replication in PLoS ONE found the effect held even when participants had another way to make up for a sense of loss[7]. Pooling the original and replication results gave a small-to-medium effect (Cohen's d = 0.43)[7].

Taken together, the experiments suggest that the sad mood that makes shopping feel helpful can also make people pay more. The line between a passing low mood and a depressive episode is covered in depression vs. sadness.

Compulsive buying disorder (CBD)

A pattern of excessive shopping thoughts and buying behavior that leads to distress or impairment. People with CBD describe a preoccupation with shopping, tension or anxiety before a purchase, and a sense of relief afterward[6].

Related Terms

compulsive shopping
oniomania
pathological buying
shopping addiction
buying-shopping disorder

Source: Black DW, World Psychiatry, 2007

Retail Therapy vs. Compulsive Buying: Where the Line Is

Compulsive buying was first described in the early 20th century by the psychiatrists Kraepelin and Bleuler, who called people with it "oniomaniacs," or buying maniacs[6]. A 2007 review in World Psychiatry describes four phases: anticipation, preparation, shopping and spending[6].

In CBD, the purchase is often followed by a let-down or disappointment with oneself[6]. That is the reverse of the regret-free mood boost documented in everyday retail therapy experiments[2].

The triggers overlap with retail therapy. In one study of compulsive buyers, negative emotions such as depression, anxiety, boredom, self-critical thoughts and anger were the most commonly cited antecedents, and euphoria or relief was the most common consequence[6].

Loss of control is the clearer dividing line. In one clinical sample, 92% of people with CBD tried to resist their urges to buy, yet 74% of urges ended in a purchase; in another, 74% felt out of control while shopping[6].

Frequent shopping alone is not evidence of the disorder, and the review advises clinicians to rule out normal buying behavior[6]. It also advises ruling out bipolar disorder, in which unrestrained spending tracks manic episodes and comes with euphoric mood and grandiosity, unlike the ongoing preoccupation seen in CBD[6].

CBD has not been officially recognized in DSM-5; among behavioral conditions, only gambling disorder sits in the manual's substance-related and addictive disorders section[5]. DSM-III-R had listed compulsive buying as an example of an impulse-control disorder not otherwise specified, but DSM-IV did not include it[6].

Everyday Retail Therapy vs. Compulsive Buying Disorder

FeatureEveryday retail therapyCompulsive buying disorder
Typical triggerSadness or a bad moodDepression, anxiety, boredom, anger
Mood afterwardImproved; no link to regret or guiltRelief, often followed by let-down
ControlShoppers can show restraint92% try to resist; most urges end in a purchase
PatternOccasional, tied to a moodOngoing preoccupation with shopping
ConsequencesNot linked to regret in studiesDistress, debt, relationship strain
Clinical statusNot a diagnosis or a treatmentNot officially recognized in DSM-5

How mood-driven shopping in consumer experiments compares with compulsive buying in clinical studies[2][1][6]

1Retail therapy findings come from laboratory and survey experiments on ordinary sadness; CBD findings come from clinical samples[6].

2DSM-5 status per a 2020 meta-analysis[5].

Sources

  • •Atalay & Meloy, 2011
  • •Rick et al., 2014
  • •Black, 2007
  • •Goslar et al., 2020

How Common Is Compulsive Buying?

A 2016 meta-analysis in Addiction pooled 49 prevalence estimates from 40 studies in 16 countries, covering about 32,000 people[4]. In representative adult samples, the pooled prevalence of compulsive buying behavior was 4.9% (range 3.4% to 6.9%)[4].

Estimates ran higher in university students (8.3%), non-representative adult samples (12.3%) and samples recruited in shopping settings (16.2%)[4]. Being younger and female was associated with higher rates, while U.S. and non-U.S. studies did not differ[4].

A 2006 U.S. survey estimated prevalence at 5.8%, with near-equal rates in men (5.5%) and women (6.0%), even though about 80% of people in clinical studies of CBD are women[6]. Onset usually falls in the late teens or early twenties[6].

CBD often co-occurs with mood, anxiety, substance use and eating disorders, as well as other impulse-control disorders[6].

Pooled prevalence of compulsive buying behavior in representative adult samples (8 estimates, 10,102 participants)
4.9%

Roughly 1 in 20 adults. Estimates rise to 8.3% among university students and vary widely with the screening tool and time frame used.

"A pooled estimate of compulsive buying behaviour in the populations studied is approximately 5%"

Maraz et al., Addiction(2016) View Source

Compulsive Buying Prevalence by Sample Type

Sample typePooled prevalenceRangeEstimatesParticipants
Representative adult samples4.9%3.4%-6.9%810,102
University students8.3%5.9%-11.5%1914,947
Non-representative adult samples12.3%7.6%-19.1%113,929
Shopping-specific samples16.2%8.8%-27.8%114,686

Pooled prevalence of compulsive buying behavior by sample type, 40 studies from 16 countries, published 2016[4]

1Large differences within groups were driven mainly by the screening measure and by whether current or lifetime buying was assessed[4].

Sources

  • •Maraz et al., Addiction, 2016
How compulsive buying is measured: Prevalence surveys identify compulsive buyers with screening questionnaires, such as the Compulsive Buying Scale used in U.S. surveys[6]. The figures describe people who screen positive, not clinically confirmed diagnoses, and results shift with the instrument and with whether current or lifetime buying is assessed[4].

Is Retail Therapy Bad for Mental Health? The Debt Connection

Occasional purchases made to lift a bad mood were not linked to regret or guilt in experiments[2]. The harm documented in the research comes when buying turns compulsive, and many people with CBD develop substantial financial problems[6].

In one clinical sample, 85% of people with CBD were concerned about their shopping-related debts, and in another, 68% said the behavior had harmed their relationships[6].

A 2013 systematic review in Clinical Psychology Review covered 65 papers on personal unsecured debt and health[8]. Its meta-analysis found debt associated with higher odds of mental disorder (OR 3.24), depression (OR 2.77) and problem drinking (OR 2.68)[8].

The authors noted a lack of longitudinal studies and cautioned that causality is hard to establish[8]. The association does not show that shopping-related debt causes mental illness, only that the two travel together.

What Treatment Research Shows for Compulsive Buying

In 2007, the World Psychiatry review concluded that there were no evidence-based treatments for CBD, though group cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) models looked promising[6]. One group CBT program produced significant improvement compared with a wait list, and gains held at 6-month follow-up[6].

A 2020 meta-analysis in the Journal of Behavioral Addictions pooled 91 studies with 3,531 participants across internet addiction, sex addiction and compulsive buying[5]. For compulsive buying, psychological treatments reduced overall severity compared with control groups (Hedges' g = 0.75 across 6 studies)[5].

Medication results were weaker than they first appear. Severity fell substantially from before to after medication treatment (g = 1.52 across 7 studies), but in the 2 controlled comparisons the difference from control was not significant (g = -0.13)[5].

The medications tested included the antidepressants fluvoxamine and citalopram and the drug memantine[5]. Across all three behaviors, face-to-face psychological treatment delivered over longer periods did better, and combining cognitive-behavioral approaches with medication showed an advantage over either alone[5].

The 2007 review also lists Debtors Anonymous, self-help books, financial counseling and marital therapy as possible parts of managing CBD[6]. Data on the broader pattern of difficulty regulating emotions are on the emotional dysregulation page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources & References

  1. Rick SI, Pereira B, Burson KA. The benefits of retail therapy: Making purchase decisions reduces residual sadness. Journal of Consumer Psychology. Published 2014. Accessed October 2026. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1057740813001149 [Link]
  2. Atalay AS, Meloy MG. Retail therapy: A strategic effort to improve mood. Psychology & Marketing. Published 2011. Accessed October 2026. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mar.20404 [Link]
  3. Cryder CE, Lerner JS, Gross JJ, Dahl RE. Misery is not miserly: Sad and self-focused individuals spend more. Psychological Science. Published 2008. Accessed October 2026. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4142804/ [Link]
  4. Maraz A, Griffiths MD, Demetrovics Z. The prevalence of compulsive buying: a meta-analysis. Addiction. Published 2016. Accessed October 2026. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/add.13223 [Link]
  5. Goslar M, Leibetseder M, Muench HM, Hofmann SG, Laireiter AR. Treatments for internet addiction, sex addiction and compulsive buying: A meta-analysis. Journal of Behavioral Addictions. Published 2020. Accessed October 2026. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8935188/ [Link]
  6. Black DW. A review of compulsive buying disorder. World Psychiatry. Published 2007. Accessed October 2026. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1805733/ [Link]
  7. Garg N, Williams LA, Lerner JS. The misery-is-not-miserly effect revisited: Replication despite opportunities for compensatory consumption. PLoS ONE. Published 2018. Accessed October 2026. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6021081/ [Link]
  8. Richardson T, Elliott P, Roberts R. The relationship between personal unsecured debt and mental and physical health: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review. Published 2013. Accessed October 2026. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0272735813001256 [Link]

Related Statistics